The Mystery of Quantum: Can One Clock Tick at Different Speeds Simultaneously? Kyushu University and Others Propose a Way to Verify

The Mystery of Quantum: Can One Clock Tick at Different Speeds Simultaneously? Kyushu University and Others Propose a Way to Verify

Spending an entire day at the observation deck of Tokyo Skytree results in experiencing slightly more time than those on the ground. The difference is about 4 billionths of a second. It's too small to feel, but if you place a precise clock on the ground floor and another at the 450-meter-high observation deck, you can actually measure it. This was an experiment announced in 2020 by RIKEN and the University of Tokyo.

Here, the discussion can be divided into two parts. The clock on the ground marks time as experienced on the ground, and the clock at the observation deck marks time as experienced there. By comparing the two, the difference becomes apparent.

So, what if we reduce it to just one clock? If that clock were made of a single atom and could simultaneously take on different motions, could the time marked by that atom be expressed as a single number? An international research team, including Associate Professor Joshua Foo from Kyushu University, proposed a method to test this question with an actual clock in the physics journal 'Physical Review Letters.'


"How many seconds have passed for that clock?"

In physics, the time marked by a clock along its path is called "proper time." The Skytree experiment was influenced by gravity due to height. The current proposal uses another well-known effect. From the same laboratory, the progression of a moving clock changes slightly depending on its speed.

The main subject of the clock envisioned by the team is a single ion, an electrically charged atom. The ion is trapped in a small region using an electric field, and a laser is applied. Inside the ion, there are states with different energy levels, and the very regular rhythm between these states can be read as the clock's hands.

What's interesting is that the trapped ion still has room to move. Moreover, according to quantum mechanics, a single ion can be prepared in a "superposition" of states with different kinetic energies. If the progression of the clock changes according to each motion, the differences in motion should be imprinted on the rhythm corresponding to the clock's hands inside the same ion.


Looking for a slightly faded "wave pattern"

What kind of result would indicate that this change has been captured? Reading the clock just once won't display two times side by side. The research team focused on the pattern that emerges when measurements are repeated under the same conditions.

First, the internal state of the ion is prepared with a laser, allowed to change freely for a while, and then the laser is applied again. By slightly shifting the wave of the second laser and repeating the measurements, the probability of finding the ion in a certain state rises and falls. When graphed, peaks and troughs appear. The difference between these peaks and troughs is the "contrast" of the interference signal.

Calculations show that the internal rhythm of the ion shifts slightly depending on its motion. Eventually, it becomes impossible to describe how the ion moved and how far the clock's hands advanced separately. This is "quantum entanglement." When only the internal state corresponding to the clock's hands is read, the difference between peaks and troughs becomes smaller. The trace of the connection between motion and time marking remains as a fading wave pattern.


What does "about 93%" represent?

This fading is usually very small. Therefore, the team incorporated a method called "squeezing" to adjust the quantum fluctuations of the ion's motion. By changing the distribution of variations in position and momentum, the differences in clock progression due to motion become more pronounced in the reading signal.

In the example shown in the paper, using an aluminum ion and maintaining the quantum relationship for about one second under the assumed conditions, the contrast becomes about 93% of the original. If the initial difference between peaks and troughs is 100, it becomes 93. Here, the approximately 7% reduction refers to the clarity of the pattern, not the length of one second marked by the clock.

The challenge in the experiment is also how to interpret that approximately 7%. Fluctuations in the laser or disturbances from outside can also make the peaks and troughs shallower. Depending on how much the ion's motion was adjusted and how long the wait was, if the contrast changes as predicted by theory, it would be a step beyond merely observing a weakened signal.


The SNS buzz: "Which 60 seconds is real?"

Regarding the progression of time, a question was posted on the English-speaking forum Reddit. It asked whether a person left on Earth and their twin on a high-speed spaceship, each counting 60 seconds with a stopwatch, could count in unison if there were no delay in communication.

 

A respondent questioned how to determine the "real one second" common to both. There was also a point made that the very setting of instantaneous communication is incompatible with the theory of relativity. Although this exchange is not a direct response to the current paper, it well illustrates the tendency to want to place a "universal stopwatch" somewhere in the universe when comparing clocks.

In the twin story, each can compare how many seconds they counted on their own clock when they reunite. What's even more intriguing about the current proposal is that the clock is a single ion from start to finish. How to extract the time difference corresponding to different motions from the signal of a single clock is where the ingenuity of this research lies.


What was measured with two clocks, and what will be measured with a single atom

At Tokyo Skytree, the readings of two clocks were compared to measure the time difference due to height. The current research shows what kind of equipment and methods can approach the questions beyond that. By precisely controlling the ion's motion, preserving delicate quantum states, and distinguishing the predicted changes in contrast, experimental verification is yet to come.

If confirmed, it will reveal that even the seemingly simple question of "how many seconds have passed for this clock?" cannot be explained by merely assigning a single elapsed time. The first clue might be the slightly faded peaks and troughs appearing in the laboratory graph.


Source